It’s strange times for the global dairy market, and one of the crazier things we’re seeing is how the butterfat market has performed lately.
The developing drift from El Nino to La Nina will take a while to provide tangible benefits to producers across southern regions, but in the meantime the numbers of cows sent to abattoirs is likely – on early production numbers at least – to take milk output to its lowest point since the mid-1990s.
Much has been written about the profound effects of the cut in milk prices on farmer profitability and the damaged trust in a couple of major milk processors.
But there are other larger impacts to come.
Firstly, an adjustment of this magnitude - somewhere between 5-10% of national milk output, mostly felt across southern regions - will push up costs in the supply chain for milk processing and affect the strength of the sector for several years.
Lower factory throughput will reduce plant profitability and continue to hurt farmgate prices for all producers.
Secondly, if milk volumes fall below 9 billion litres, the effect will push the domestic share of milk processed closer to 70%.
But does this mean it changes the determinants of farmgate prices, so that the world market will have less influence on milk values? No, that’s something that won’t change.
We’re effectively an open market for cheese, butterfat and milk powders and have a large low-cost exporter across the Tasman that views this market as part of its home ground.
A number of large multinational groups – fast food chains and large food brands – operate with global sourcing policies, reinforcing the fact that world prices set wholesale prices in the Australian market.
Why is pricing made so tough by food companies?
There are no significant segments of the food market in Australia that are immune from price pressure, whether through grocery stores, convenience outlets, fast food or other dining out venues.
Sure, there are niches that create premiums for a limited number of players, but if they get too big they quickly risk being “commoditised”.
That brings us to the grocery market, the largest channel to consumers for Australian dairy products, where the operating environment will probably get a little worse.
Australia’s two major supermarket chains posted their 2016 results last month, and the contrast between Coles and Woolworths couldn’t have been greater.
Coles’ “trusted value” pitch to consumers is still the single biggest shaper of the Australian food market, and has worked very well for Wesfarmers shareholders.
Coles lifted earnings by a small 4% this year, but profitability has grown 60% over the past 5 years in the midst of a deep-discounting war waged for consumer trust, while it grew its supermarket business sales by 30% on 8% more store numbers.
Coles underlying business rose more than 4% on a comparable “same-stores” basis.
But the scariest number for Australian food producers is the underlying food price deflation, which was almost 2% in 2015/16, and has been in deflationary mode since the post-GFC tightening really got underway in 2009.
At the other end of the spectrum, the sustained attack from Coles and the swelling influence discounter Aldi finally came home to roost for Woolworths, which reported the unthinkable for a big grocery player - a fall in sales of its food business.
Stagnant sales caused profits to crash, down 40%, as retailing margins collapsed from more than 7% to 4.5%.
For many years Woolworths has claimed it was defending its world-beating margins yet, in a single year, they fell below Coles’ which has run a leaner business.
Some analysts have criticised Woolies for keeping prices too high, now the new regime has committed to funding more price cuts.
I can hear those bleeding hearts out there while I write this, ‘so why should you care?’
As the dairy value chain feels the pain of shrinkage, the biggest market for milk just got tighter, if that was possible.
The supermarket stakes will get higher and the long, hard contests between the big three will now drag on as Woolworths attempts a major turnaround.
Meanwhile the economy isn’t getting any better, as household incomes in real terms have been slowing down – suggesting “value” will still be important to many grocery buyers.
Some things might be a little different however.
Retail analysts that we follow point to signs that the average shopper is getting a little jaded with specials and savings, as discounts are less-effective at cutting through and moving traffic between stores and shifting products off the shelves.
Both big chains might have to create a bit more excitement in their brands to draw more cash from purses and wallets.
On the other hand, it is apparent that the scrutiny by shoppers and the community of the treatment of suppliers is getting stronger and that a growing realisation that “cheap for the sake of cheap” isn’t a great outcome for all.
We’ll see if that gains more traction going forward, or whether the compulsion to “follow Aldi” is just too great.