Wednesday, 13 April 2011 14:00

Nobody wins when Govt in two minds

Written by 

THE FEDERAL Government seems to have two gears – flat out and stationary.

When it comes to finalising the Murray-Darling Basin Plan it is moving at breakneck pace to get legislation written and tabled this year – despite community pleas to slow down to ensure everyone’s views are considered.

When it comes to action on last year’s Senate Inquiry into competition and pricing in the Australian dairy industry, the gear stick is still in park.

A spokesman for MP David Bradbury – parliamentary secretary to the Treasurer – told Dairy News the Government will continue to consider the recommendations made by the Senate Committee, as well as the current inquiry that is due to report in April, and formally respond in “due course”.

That’s 12 months worth of consideration since last year’s recommendations were tabled in parliament! Yet something tells us we shouldn’t hold our breath waiting for the Government to make a move.

And if it has taken that long for a Government response on the initial inquiry, it doesn’t bode well for a speedy response to the current inquiry.

Northern dairy farmers are losing money as a direct result of Coles cutting prices and the Government continues to sit on its hands.

In stark contrast, Prime Minister Gillard has shown no signs of deviating from the original Murray Darling Basin Plan deadline this year. The draft plan is expected to be published this year and the Prime Minister has said Water Minister Tony Burke will sign off a plan later in the year.

The Victorian and NSW Governments, and key irrigation groups, have asked for the current guide to Basin Plan – which calls for a diversion of 3000-7600 gigalitres of irrigation water – to be re-drafted. They claim the drought-breaking rain across the country over summer has provided enough water for the Murray-Darling Basin for a couple of years. This provides the time to enable all parties to work on a consensual plan, they claim.

So what’s the rush?

Burke and new MDBA chairman Craig Knowles have publicly questioned the Water Act, which they say gives the environment precedence over all. Meanwhile, the CSIRO has attacked the credibility of the “science” behind the required diversion figures outlined in the plan.

Pushing a new plan through without proper consultation will damage any chances of securing the health of both the river system and rural communities. It’s a balancing act that will require time and careful consideration.

Unfortunately, neither appear likely from the Government.

More from this category

Milking It...

A rod for their back

A shortage of labour is a bugbear for most farmers, but how many would think this would be a problem on a prison farm?

Help needed as farmers recover

IMAGES COMING from Queensland have been horrific. There is no other way to describe them.

The stories of local residents losing everything – from a lifetime of possessions and memories in a flood-affected house, to livestock washed away down the river – can reduce you to tears.

China and India will shape global market


DEVELOPMENTS OVER the last 12 months have changed Rabobank’s view on the likely role of China and India in the world marketplace through to 2014.

Long advocates of the likely self-sufficiency of these markets, Rabobank now believes that China faces a structural market deficit that will be difficult to erode in coming years.

GENOMICS HAS hit the dairy breeding industry by storm.

During the past couple of years, we have gone from almost no application of genomic/genetic marker results in breeding programs to widespread use of genomics.

THERE'S NEVER been a more important time for the Federal Government to look at the big picture when preparing policy.

A NEW report on progress of the Commonwealth water buyback for the Murray Darling indicates that the two tender rounds that were held in Queensland's Lower Balonne have been undersubscribed, leaving most of the budget of $140 million unspent.

The new milk season looms as a period of consolidation for most Australian farmers but we are starting to see a concerning divergence of fortunes between those in south eastern Australia and those in Queensland, northern NSW and Western Australia.

WORKING WITH teams both sides of the Tasman enables me to see various approaches to getting the best out of people. So I'm thinking about teamwork, in particular the merits of different leadership styles.

Leave a comment

Make sure you enter the (*) required information where indicated.\nBasic HTML code is allowed.

» Get social

When butter and chocolate collide

TWO New Zealand companies Lewis Road Creamery and Whittakers have teamed up to deliver what must be every dairy lover’s dream: chocolate butter.

» E-Newsletter

Subscribe to our mailing list

* indicates required