Echuca’s Pastoral Hotel owner fined

Mr Andrews was sentenced with conviction and fined $5000 and $87.20 in court costs, a sentencing that he said he intended to appeal.

During his hearing on August 17, Mr Andrews pleaded not guilty and argued police didn’t have the power to lay the charge or prosecute the matter.

Prosecutor Senior Constable Sofo told the court COVID-19 restrictions at the time permitted hospitality venues to operate only for takeaway services.

He said police officers attended the pub and spoke to Mr Andrews between July 19 and 21, 2021, where they found patrons playing pool, sitting down for meals and drinking at the bar.

Mr Andrews, who was representing himself in court, was accompanied by about 20 supporters.

He asked for the case to be dismissed on account of the fact that he had no relevant prior convictions.

Sen Constable Sofo argued that the state had a significant role to play in protecting the public.

“He was warned multiple times and he purposely ignored those warnings,” he said.

Judicial registrar Allison Vaughan said it was “an obvious and deliberate breach” of the Chief Health Officer’s directions.

“I am not persuaded by the arguments that you have raised,” Ms Vaughan said.

“I am satisfied that the prosecution of the case is in accordance with the legislation.

“You took it upon yourself to breach the law because you wanted to operate the hotel. If everyone took that approach, we would have been in a world of trouble.”

Ms Vaughan said she understood that businesses experienced significant hardship throughout the pandemic.

“I understand that hotels in small towns are more than just a pub. I appreciate that you provide more of a service than just a parma and pot,” she said.

“But the reality is that there were so many businesses that suffered.

“The court is not satisfied that you have raised a valid defence.”